Saturday, September 11, 2010

Broken symmetry, broken heart

A week ago, we had a very interesting Physics department colloquium by Marcelo Gleiser about his recent book, A Tear at the Edge of Creation: A Radical New Vision for Life in an Imperfect Cosmos. 
He discussed his growing disillusion with string theory and the search for a "theory of everything" which is based on the predominance of symmetry. He gave important examples of symmetry breaking in nature including CP violation in the electro-weak interactions [which because of the CPT theorem implies time reversal invariance] and the unique chirality of amino acids in proteins.
Although it was a nice talk I thought it was all a bit sad to see someone who had become so enamoured with the propaganda of the reductionism in the high-energy physics community that it was painful when doubts emerged. Most of the points Gleiser was making seem to me to have been made long ago (in a more constructive sense) by Anderson in his 1972 "More is Different" article in Science, and more passionately and more recently by Laughlin in A Different Universe. 

1 comment:

  1. I did not see the point / problem with the existence of broken symmetries in nature. In any finite group there will be operations that are not a symmetry. The fact that CP is not a symmetry seems less profound (or at least, no more profound) than the fact that CPT IS a symmetry.

    ReplyDelete

Science job openings in sunny Brisbane, Australia

Bribie Island, just north of Brisbane. The University of Queensland has just advertised several jobs that may be of interest to readers of t...