What is really fundamental in science?
What do we mean when we say something in science is fundamental? When is an entity or a theory more fundamental or less fundamental than something else? For example, are quarks and leptons more fundamental than atoms? Is statistical mechanics more fundamental than thermodynamics? Is physics more fundamental than chemistry or biology? In a fractional quantum Hall state, are electrons or the fractionally charged quasiparticles more fundamental? Answers depend on who you ask. Physicists such as Phil Anderson, Steven Weinberg, Bob Laughlin, Richard Feynman, Frank Wilczek, and Albert Einstein have different views. In 2017-8, the Foundational Questions Institute (FQXi) held an essay contest to address the question, “What is Fundamental?” Of the 200 entries, 15 prize-winning essays have been published in a single volume. The editors give a nice overview in the Introduction. This post is mostly about the essay, Fundamental? of the first prize winner, Emily Adlam , a philosopher of physics. Sh