I have a dream. That every advisor (supervisor) who gets a student to perform a computational chemistry calculation will have them read the following five papers. The papers are from a range of eras and with different emphasis. But, a common theme is the importance of calculations aiding concept development and being aware of the limitations these calculations.
Reading these papers should be like reading the road rules before you get your drivers license.
I list the papers in chronological order.
Present state of molecular structure calculations
C.A. Coulson (1960)
Quantum chemistry and its unachieved missions
Jean-Paul Malrieu (1998)
Is my chemical universe localized or delocalized? is there a future for chemical concepts?
Sason Shaik (2007)
Predicting Molecules - More realism , please!
Roald Hoffmann, Paul Schleyer, and Fritz Schaefer (2008)
Some Fundamental Issues in Ground-State Density Functional Theory: A Guide for the Perplexed
John P. Perdew, Adrienn Ruzsinszky, Lucian Constantin, Jianwei Sun, and Gabor Csonka (2009)
I welcome alternative suggestions. Later I may write more about the individual papers and why I think they are important.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Emergence and protein folding
Proteins are a distinct state of matter. Globular proteins are tightly packed with a density comparable to a crystal but without the spatia...
-
Is it something to do with breakdown of the Born-Oppenheimer approximation? In molecular spectroscopy you occasionally hear this term thro... -
If you look on the arXiv and in Nature journals there is a continuing stream of people claiming to observe superconductivity in some new mat...
-
I welcome discussion on this point. I don't think it is as sensitive or as important a topic as the author order on papers. With rega...
Thanks for this list...
ReplyDeletethanks for this. Its 2016, are still going to update this blog?
ReplyDeleteHi Unknown,
ReplyDeleteHere are some more recent articles that highlight some of the issues about simulations. They come from one of the most respected computational chemistry groups at the forefront of large-molecule simulation (on GPUs). It is interesting to note that the problems com out in force BECAUSE the computational developments allow an approach to larger problems. They are a demonstration that improved computational abilities, reasonably applied, allow a more critical assessment of the methods as they scale up, and can expose their deficiencies:
DOI: 10.1021/jp4058274 (from 2013)
arXiv preprint arXiv:1505.05730 (from 2015)
DOI: 10.1021/ct3006826 (from 2013)