Discovering power laws is an important thing in physics.
Often people claim they have evidence for one.
My question is:
Over how many orders of magnitude must the data follow the apparent power law for you to believe it?
Often I read papers or hear speakers showing just one decade (or less!).
Is this convincing? Is it important?
Personally, I find that my prejudice is that I need to see at least 1.5 decades before I even take notice. Two decades is convincing and three or more is impressive.
What do other people think?
Some of the most important power laws are those associated with critical phenomena (and scaling). The most impressive experiments see thermodynamic quantities which depend on a power of the deviation from the critical temperature by many orders of magnitude. My favourite experiment involved superfluid helium on the space shuttle and observed scaling over 7 decades!
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
What criteria should be used to evaluate theories of emergence properties?
What criteria do people use to decide if a theory in physics is successful? For special relativity, general relativity, and quantum theory, ...
-
An interesting and controversial question for Ph.D's in science and engineering is too what extent students should be expected to have ...
-
Some of my colleagues and I have started an interesting discussion about how to teach quantum theory to undergraduates. We have courses in t...
-
As years go by the PhD thesis in science and engineering is less and less of a ``thesis'' and more just a box to tick. There was a t...
A related question: what are the best examples of quantum critical scaling? My impression was that no observation has come anyway close to the gold standard set by those space shuttle measurements on classical critical phenomena.
ReplyDelete