Thursday, March 31, 2011

Breaking down the physics-chemistry divide

Chemists and physicists tend to talk different languages, including when discussing the same thing. One important parallel is the common concept of the molecular orbitals in a molecule and the energy bands in a crystal. Specifically, the Huckel method to describe electronic properties of conjugated organic molecules is identical to the tight-binding method in solid state physics.

Yet these important parallels seem to rarely be pointed out in textbooks. [One exception is a brief mention in Walter Harrison's Electronic Structure and the Properties of Solids].
Recently when I have taught solid state I have pointed out the connection and sometimes worked through the nice treatment of Huckel theory in chapter 8 of the classic book Coulson's Valence by Roy McWeeny.
Besides showing the molecule-solid connection this can illustrate a few useful things including:
  • How Bloch's theorem works in a finite system.
  • How energy bands emerge in the thermodynamic limit (see above).
  • The correspondence between bonding (anti-bonding) orbitals in a molecule and valence (conduction) bands in a crystal.
  • The potential importance of electron-electron interactions, which are completely neglected in both Huckel and tight-binding approximations. Valence bond theory takes these interactions into account.
Any other ideas?

Some of the above parallels are explored in more detail in a beautiful article How Chemistry and Physics meet in the Solid State by Roald Hoffmann, and in a forthcoming book chapter by Ben Powell.

4 comments:

  1. Nice!
    This approach gives me a lucid way to connect physicists and chemists and then lead them both into quantum approaches to understanding biochemistry and biology.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Dudley Herschbach wrote an illuminating column about physics-versus-chemistry for Physics Today's April 1997 issue entitled "Chemistry: Blithe Sibling of Physics"—Charles Day

    ReplyDelete
  3. I think one of the more important connections to make using Huckel/TB theory is influence of symmetry and bond connectivity on the band-structure (and correspondingly the molecular orbitals).

    ReplyDelete
  4. A habitual homework problem of mine to give to my Intro to Cond Mat Students is an involved treatment of the tight-binding model for a 6 site ring e.g. benzene. They get a little dizzy at first when I present the problem in terms of chemistr/LCAO language, but then they thank me (and hopefully understand it better), by the time they are through!

    ReplyDelete

From Leo Szilard to the Tasmanian wilderness

Richard Flanagan is an esteemed Australian writer. My son recently gave our family a copy of Flanagan's recent book, Question 7 . It is...