Thursday, January 15, 2015

Satire of reductionism run amok

The "cartoon" below appeared at CERN.
I learnt about it from a commenter on Peter Woit's excellent blog, Not even wrong.


Note, "The problem of condensed matter: they still don't get it".

3 comments:

  1. I must confess that as a cond-mat physicist I don't even get the joke...

    Adam

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi Adam,

      It is subtle. I probably only appreciate it because I follow Peter Woit's blog. He does an excellent job exposing/critiquing string theorists who seem to claim SuperSymmetry (SUSY) and string theory is true, regardless of what experiment says.

      The poster is a nice parody of many issues that come up on Peter's blog.

      I take the comment about condensed matter to be a dig at theorists who just don't get the idea of emergence and think that reductionism is the answer to everything. I also take it to be a possible dig at the AdS/CFT crowd who claim string theory is going to solve condensed matter problems; and are bemused that some of us don't share their excitement or buy into their hype.

      Delete
    2. Hi,

      I know Peter's blog (I saw the poster in the comments there too), it's just the joke on cond-mat physicists that I found cryptic. But your explanation makes sense.
      Adam

      Delete

Quantum states of matter and metrology

Two characteristics of states of matter are associated with them being referred to as quantum. One characteristic is the importance of quant...