Tuesday, September 25, 2012

A twisted quantum chemical vision

There is an interesting paper in Science
The Molecular Mechanism of Thermal Noise in Rod Photoreceptors

Samer Gozem, Igor Schapiro, Nicolas Ferré,  and Massimo Olivucci

The abstract is quite clear.
Spontaneous electrical signals in the retina's photoreceptors impose a limit on visual sensitivity. Their origin is attributed to a thermal, rather than photochemical, activation of the transduction cascade. Although the mechanism of such a process is under debate, the observation of a relationship between the maximum absorption wavelength (λmax) and the thermal activation kinetic constant (k) of different visual pigments (the Barlow correlation) indicates that the thermal and photochemical activations are related. Here we show that a quantum chemical model of the bovine rod pigment provides a molecular-level understanding of the Barlow correlation. The transition state mediating thermal activation has the same electronic structure as the photoreceptor excited state, thus creating a direct link between λmax and k. Such a link appears to be the manifestation of intrinsic chromophore features associated with the existence of a conical intersection between its ground and excited states.

If you want a "spherical cow" view of the quantum physics read the beginning of this nice paper by Irene Burghardt and J.T. Hynes.

Monday, September 24, 2012

Marketing the Higgs boson

The level of media coverage (and hype) associated with the Higgs boson announcement in July caught me by surprise. But, then I realised that if you spend $10 billion on an experiment there must be some very small fraction associated with publicity and outreach. So I did some Googling and found this CERN document which gives the annual marketing budget as slightly less than $2 million. 
Combining this with 10,000 physicists from around the world hitting their local media outlets I should not have been surprised at the level of publicity.

Friday, September 21, 2012

A helpful sentence to write in any paper

This equation/figure/table is the central result of this paper.

I love to read a sentence such as this. First, it helps me know what the paper is about. Second, it helps me decide whether the paper is important and I should read it in detail. Third, it provides a framework to try and understand the rest of the paper.

Some might complain that their paper contains so many "important" results that it is not possible to identify a single equation or figure which is central. However, I doubt this is true. And if it really is true I would encourage breaking up the paper into several publons.

Thursday, September 20, 2012

Do you really want to get promoted so soon?

This might seem like a strange idea. Surely everyone wants to get promoted as quickly as possible and to get the associated pay rises?

This post occurs in the context that in some Australian universities it is possible to get promoted through the academic ranks without having tenure. But, even if you have tenure there are reasons why you might not want to get promoted so quickly.

Your primary goal should be to be have a permanent job in a good institution in a place where you and your family want to live. Promotion may make this primary goal harder.

If you don't have tenure and get promoted you may price yourself out of the market of possible permanent jobs or fellowship awards.
In a similar vein, even if you have tenure and hope to make a move to another institution (or country) either for personal or professional reasons, you need to be careful that you also don't price yourself out of the desired market.
For example, suppose you are an Australian living in the UK and you desparately want to return home (understandable!). If you become a Professor in the UK this will significantly limit the routes whereby you can return.

Finally, remember that the more senior you are the more you may be expected to take on more administrative and "leadership" roles. On the flip side, a common "carrot" for people aiming for promotion is to get them to thank on thankless and time-consuming admin tasks that count as "service" in their promotion case. Ask yourself, "Is it worth it?"

In most institutions the best way to get tenure and to get promoted is to get a nice offer from another institution.

Wednesday, September 19, 2012

Testing the Morse potential

A while back I asked about How good is the Morse potential at describing the potential energy of a chemical bond as a function of stretching of the bond length?

Today I learnt (from Atkins Physical Chemistry text) that Birge-Sponer extrapolation plots provide a means to test the potential all the way up to the disassociation limit. One plots the difference in energy/frequency between neighbouring transitions. If the plot is linear and then where it extrapolates provides a means to determine the disassociation energy.
The Figure above shows a plot for an excited state of the iodine diatomic molecule. The plot is linear all the way up to quantum numbers of order 50. It is taken from this paper.

There is a nice article in Journal of Chemical Education which describes how all of this is (or can be) done in undergraduate Physical Chemistry labs. Pity I missed out...

Tuesday, September 18, 2012

Chemistry is quantum science

Owing to its pervasive dependence on the superposition phenomenon, chemistry truly deserves to be called “the quantum science”.
This is the concluding sentence of a beautiful article Chemical Bonding as a Superposition Phenomenon by Frank Weinhold in the Journal of Chemical Education. 
It is a nice easy introduction to physicists who want to start to get some sense of what chemical bonding is all about.

A key idea is that because of the superposition principle that as two chemical units [whether atoms or molecules] are brought closer together, the composite system can lower its energy by being in a superposition state, as illustrated below.
Although the article discusses this idea at the one electron level it is important to realise that this superposition is also relevant for many-body wavefunctions.

The article does not discuss the variational principle but probably should have. This is intimately connected with superposition and plays a central role in computational quantum chemistry.

The paper also mentions that superposition is at the heart of quantum entanglement, and thus at the heart of quantum weirdness. However, no hints are given of how entanglement may actually play a role in quantum chemistry. That turns out to be a slippery subject, e.g. giving a clear and well-defined measure of entanglement in a simple molecule.

Weinhold's ideas are expanded in great detail in the beautiful book  Valency and Bonding: A Natural Bond Orbital Donor-Acceptor Perspective, co-authored with Clark Landis.

Monday, September 17, 2012

Failure of the spherical cow approximation

Physicists think cows are spherical. But are they?
There is a very nice Perspective in Science Spare the (Elastic) Rod by Phil Nelson. He discusses recent experiments on DNA which show the limitations/breakdown of the much loved [at least by physicists] elastic model rod model for a polymer. This beautifully simple model has only a single parameter, the persistence length, on which length scale it is assumed that the polymer is inflexible. The models shows that the elasticity (on long length scales) of the polymer is due to entropic effects. For DNA the persistence length is estimated to be about one hundred base pairs.

This model is so simple that it can be taught in an undergraduate statistical mechanics class. The mathematics is analogous to a paramagnetic in a magnetic field. Slightly different versions go by names such as Freely Jointed Chain and Worm Like Chain.
A nice review is by Cocco, Marko, and Monasson and contains the helpful figure below.

Emergence and centralised planning of scientific research

 Scientists, individually and collectively, make decisions about research directions and priorities. There are three main interacting influe...