Thursday, May 13, 2010

Keeping editors happy

How should you respond to referee reports when you re-submit a paper?

I have never been the Editor of a journal but I think they really appreciate it if you do the following in your cover letter:

Abstain from derogatory comments about the referee(s).

Explicitly re-state each objection of the referee before responding to it.
(Paraphrases may be suspect, either missing the point for mis-representing it.)
Then respond to the objection.
Finally, clearly state how and where you have modified the manuscript in response to this criticism.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Elastic interactions and complex patterns in binary systems

One of the many beauties of condensed matter physics is that it can reveal and illuminate how two systems or phenomena that at first appear ...