Thursday, May 13, 2010

Keeping editors happy

How should you respond to referee reports when you re-submit a paper?

I have never been the Editor of a journal but I think they really appreciate it if you do the following in your cover letter:

Abstain from derogatory comments about the referee(s).

Explicitly re-state each objection of the referee before responding to it.
(Paraphrases may be suspect, either missing the point for mis-representing it.)
Then respond to the objection.
Finally, clearly state how and where you have modified the manuscript in response to this criticism.

No comments:

Post a Comment

A very effective Hamiltonian in nuclear physics

Atomic nuclei are complex quantum many-body systems. Effective theories have helped provide a better understanding of them. The best-known a...