Both things we desperately want to believe. We tell them to our colleagues.
The first may also be told by department chairs to try and persuade someone to teach a course.
The second we may tell prospective students.
1.
Teaching this course for the first time won't really take that much time.
I won't be a perfectionist. I will cut corners. After all, I have someone else's notes (and assignments, exams, ...). It is a really good textbook....
2.
My student can complete their Ph.D in the minimum amount of time [3 years in Australia].
They will work really hard. They are smart. They will cut corners. I will supervise them closely. The project is quite straight-forward. I won't repeat past mistakes...
Face it. Neither is true.
Or do you believe them?
Why or why not?
Wednesday, October 3, 2012
Tuesday, October 2, 2012
Breakdown of the Luttinger liquid paradigm
At the Journal Club for Condensed Matter Patrick Lee has a helpful commentary on a recent preprint
Non-Fermi liquid d-wave metal phase of strongly interacting electrons
Hong-Chen Jiang, Matthew S. Block, Ryan V. Mishmash, James R. Garrison, D. N. Sheng, Olexei I. Motrunich, Matthew P. A. Fisher
The preprint presents numerical evidence that a t-J model on a ladder with a particular kind of ring exchange has an exotic ground state.
This state is particularly interesting for two reasons.
First, it falls outside the Luttinger liquid paradigm which is the one-dimensional version of Landau's Fermi liquid theory.
Second, this exotic state is well described by a variational wave function based on the "parton" construction [a generalisation of slave bosons] where electron operators are replaced by a product of three fermion operators.
The million dollar question remains: is any of this relevant to two dimensions?
The authors state, "estimating the strength of K [ring exchange] .... in real materials such as La2-xSrxCuO4 is an interesting question."
This is particularly important because they require K larger than the hopping t to get the non-Fermi liquid phase.
I thought the ring exchange was the four spin ring exchange occurs in solid 3He and in a weak Mott insulator. However, it is different. As the figure above shows this "ring exchange" involves spatially rotating spin singlets. I thank Matthew Fisher for clarifying my confusion on this point.
For the parent Mott insulator La2CuO4 the magnitude of the 4-spin ring exchange was determined by inelastic neutron scattering a decade ago by Radu Coldea and collaborators. It is smaller than t.
Previously, I posted about nice related work by some of the same authors, on a Heisenberg model with 4 spin-ring exchange on a multi-leg ladder. This model is directly relevant to the possible spin liquid state in organic charge transfer salts.
Non-Fermi liquid d-wave metal phase of strongly interacting electrons
Hong-Chen Jiang, Matthew S. Block, Ryan V. Mishmash, James R. Garrison, D. N. Sheng, Olexei I. Motrunich, Matthew P. A. Fisher
The preprint presents numerical evidence that a t-J model on a ladder with a particular kind of ring exchange has an exotic ground state.
This state is particularly interesting for two reasons.
First, it falls outside the Luttinger liquid paradigm which is the one-dimensional version of Landau's Fermi liquid theory.
Second, this exotic state is well described by a variational wave function based on the "parton" construction [a generalisation of slave bosons] where electron operators are replaced by a product of three fermion operators.
The million dollar question remains: is any of this relevant to two dimensions?
The authors state, "estimating the strength of K [ring exchange] .... in real materials such as La2-xSrxCuO4 is an interesting question."
This is particularly important because they require K larger than the hopping t to get the non-Fermi liquid phase.
I thought the ring exchange was the four spin ring exchange occurs in solid 3He and in a weak Mott insulator. However, it is different. As the figure above shows this "ring exchange" involves spatially rotating spin singlets. I thank Matthew Fisher for clarifying my confusion on this point.
For the parent Mott insulator La2CuO4 the magnitude of the 4-spin ring exchange was determined by inelastic neutron scattering a decade ago by Radu Coldea and collaborators. It is smaller than t.
Previously, I posted about nice related work by some of the same authors, on a Heisenberg model with 4 spin-ring exchange on a multi-leg ladder. This model is directly relevant to the possible spin liquid state in organic charge transfer salts.
Monday, October 1, 2012
A highly original model for water
I find it is rare that I read a paper that I think is highly original and creative. One I read recently is
Water Modeled As an Intermediate Element between Carbon and Silicon
by Valeria Molinero and Emily Moore
They model water molecules as single atoms! It is just like a spherical cow. And it works..
The abstract of the paper is beautifully written and very informative and so I reproduce it here.
The authors recently used this model in a Nature paper,
Water Modeled As an Intermediate Element between Carbon and Silicon
by Valeria Molinero and Emily Moore
They model water molecules as single atoms! It is just like a spherical cow. And it works..
The abstract of the paper is beautifully written and very informative and so I reproduce it here.
Water and silicon are chemically dissimilar substances with common physical properties. Their liquids display a temperature of maximum density, increased diffusivity on compression, and they form tetrahedral crystals and tetrahedral amorphous phases. The common feature to water, silicon, and carbon is the formation of tetrahedrally coordinated units. We exploit these similarities to develop a coarse-grained model of water (mW) [monatomic Water] that is essentially an atom with tetrahedrality intermediate between carbon and silicon. mW mimics the hydrogen-bonded structure of water through the introduction of a nonbond angular dependent term that encourages tetrahedral configurations.
The model departs from the prevailing paradigm in water modeling: the use of long-ranged forces (electrostatics) to produce short-ranged (hydrogen-bonded) structure.
mW has only short-range interactions yet it reproduces the energetics, density and structure of liquid water, and its anomalies and phase transitions with comparable or better accuracy than the most popular atomistic models of water, at less than 1% of the computational cost.
We conclude that it is not the nature of the interactions but the connectivity of the molecules that determines the structural and thermodynamic behavior of water.
The speedup in computing time provided by mW makes it particularly useful for the study of slow processes in deeply supercooled water, the mechanism of ice nucleation, wetting-drying transitions, and as a realistic water model for coarse-grained simulations of biomolecules and complex materials.The success of the model highlights how the properties of liquid water are emergent.
The authors recently used this model in a Nature paper,
Structural transformation in supercooled water controls the crystallization rate of ice
Friday, September 28, 2012
Moneyball in academia?
I watched the movie Moneyball with my family. There was a scene which reminded me of a number of conversations I have had over the years concerning hiring young faculty. The scene features in the trailer below. Billy Beane [Brad Pitt], general manager of the Oakland As major league baseball team is sitting at a table with the club scouts and they are discussing which players to recruit, particularly because they just lost a couple of star players.
The scene highlights how they use arbitrary subjective criteria to endorse or dismiss particular players. ["He has an ugly girlfriend and so must lack self-confidence"!]
How is this like academia?
Unfortunately, the same thing can happen. People can get very emotional and subjective, like in the movie. Over the years, colleagues from a range of institutions have told me how they (or their department) desperately want to hire a particular individual and will "mortgage the farm" to do it.
But, is the individual really worth it? I can remember specific cases over the past 15 years where this has not proven to be the case. In fact, in some cases the individuals concerned are not even doing science any more.
Is the solution using metrics to evaluate potential performance, as in the baseball movie?
No, but it is important to acknowledge that it is fairly difficult to predict future performance. Billy Beane makes that point about himself. He was the high school graduate everyone wanted. But, he flopped in major league baseball.
The scene highlights how they use arbitrary subjective criteria to endorse or dismiss particular players. ["He has an ugly girlfriend and so must lack self-confidence"!]
How is this like academia?
Unfortunately, the same thing can happen. People can get very emotional and subjective, like in the movie. Over the years, colleagues from a range of institutions have told me how they (or their department) desperately want to hire a particular individual and will "mortgage the farm" to do it.
But, is the individual really worth it? I can remember specific cases over the past 15 years where this has not proven to be the case. In fact, in some cases the individuals concerned are not even doing science any more.
Is the solution using metrics to evaluate potential performance, as in the baseball movie?
No, but it is important to acknowledge that it is fairly difficult to predict future performance. Billy Beane makes that point about himself. He was the high school graduate everyone wanted. But, he flopped in major league baseball.
One minute physics
Maybe you all know all about Minute physics.
But only this week I got introduced (by my wife!) .
We watched Why the Higgs is the missing link and
I think they highlight the value of simple whiteboard talks.
But only this week I got introduced (by my wife!) .
We watched Why the Higgs is the missing link and
I think they highlight the value of simple whiteboard talks.
Thursday, September 27, 2012
Geometric distinctions between metals and insulators
Raffaele Resta has a very helpful review article The insulating state of matter: a geometrical theory.
It elegantly connects what to me are a rather disparate range of topics:
Kohn's classic 1964 characterisation of insulators, Berry's phase, Chern numbers, periodic versus open boundary conditions, quantum metrics, Anderson localization, Mott insulators, Quantum Hall insulators, ....
A central quantity defines the "localisation" associated with the ground state wavefunction.
In a 1999 PRL Resta and Sorella introduced this quantity and showed how it diverged at the quantum phase transition between a band insulator and a Mott insulator in a one-dimensional ionic Hubbard model.
In a 2006 J. Chem. Phys. paper Resta connects this localisation to Boy's localisation in quantum chemistry.
It elegantly connects what to me are a rather disparate range of topics:
Kohn's classic 1964 characterisation of insulators, Berry's phase, Chern numbers, periodic versus open boundary conditions, quantum metrics, Anderson localization, Mott insulators, Quantum Hall insulators, ....
A central quantity defines the "localisation" associated with the ground state wavefunction.
In a 1999 PRL Resta and Sorella introduced this quantity and showed how it diverged at the quantum phase transition between a band insulator and a Mott insulator in a one-dimensional ionic Hubbard model.
In a 2006 J. Chem. Phys. paper Resta connects this localisation to Boy's localisation in quantum chemistry.
Wednesday, September 26, 2012
Tailor your poster to your audience
Previously I posted about the importance of tailoring a talk to the audience.
The same is true for posters.
You should not use the same poster for every conference!
The audience may be only theorists, only experimentalists, or a mix, only physicists, only chemists, a mix, only graduate students with diverse backgrounds, only specialists, .....
The background knowledge and the questions that each audience have will be dramatically different.
This post was stimulated by the recent Annual Postgraduate Poster day for the School of Mathematics and Physics at UQ. This is a great initiative as it gives students valuable experience and presenting a poster, and helps everyone get a better idea of what is going on in the School. However, I was struck by how most of the posters I looked at seemed to more appropriate for a specialist conference than for a general audience of physicists and mathematicians. Furthermore, when I asked some of the students to explain their poster to me some quickly resorted to technical jargon and I struggled to put their work in a broader context.
For such a general meeting people have really basic questions like.
What is this field about?
What are the important questions?
How does your work relate to that?
Have you got one simple concrete result that I can understand?
I am not claiming any of the above is easy. But impressing people and connecting with them never is.
The same is true for posters.
You should not use the same poster for every conference!
The audience may be only theorists, only experimentalists, or a mix, only physicists, only chemists, a mix, only graduate students with diverse backgrounds, only specialists, .....
The background knowledge and the questions that each audience have will be dramatically different.
This post was stimulated by the recent Annual Postgraduate Poster day for the School of Mathematics and Physics at UQ. This is a great initiative as it gives students valuable experience and presenting a poster, and helps everyone get a better idea of what is going on in the School. However, I was struck by how most of the posters I looked at seemed to more appropriate for a specialist conference than for a general audience of physicists and mathematicians. Furthermore, when I asked some of the students to explain their poster to me some quickly resorted to technical jargon and I struggled to put their work in a broader context.
For such a general meeting people have really basic questions like.
What is this field about?
What are the important questions?
How does your work relate to that?
Have you got one simple concrete result that I can understand?
I am not claiming any of the above is easy. But impressing people and connecting with them never is.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
Emergence and centralised planning of scientific research
Scientists, individually and collectively, make decisions about research directions and priorities. There are three main interacting influe...
-
An interesting and controversial question for Ph.D's in science and engineering is too what extent students should be expected to have ...
-
Some of my colleagues and I have started an interesting discussion about how to teach quantum theory to undergraduates. We have courses in t...
-
As years go by the PhD thesis in science and engineering is less and less of a ``thesis'' and more just a box to tick. There was a t...

