Saturday, August 25, 2012

Disciplined writing

Here are a few hints about writing papers and grant applications.

First, just do it! Start writing. Worry about all the details on the second and third rewrite.

Second, review every single sentence. Is each sentence actually true? Any claim needs to be backed up with evidence (e.g., a reference). Never offer undefendable ground. In my view, far too many papers contain assertions that are debatable. For example, "this experimental data proves theory A is correct" should be replaced with "this experimental data is consistent with theory A".

Third, reconsider qualitative language and value judgements. You may write "the agreement between my theory and experiment is excellent" but others might think it is not particularly impressive. Perhaps it is better to be more circumspect and write "the theory and experiment are compared in Figure X" and let the reader make their own judgement.

Fourth, avoid vagueness. Be concrete, precise, specific, and informative. Instead of writing "there are lots of different theories of high-temperature superconductors" write something like "the diverse range of theories of the phase diagram of cuprate superconductors include theories that focus on resonating valence bonds, antiferromagnetic spin fluctuations, van-Hove singularities, quantum critical points,...." and give specific references.

Fifth, get feedback from others.

Sixth, keep at it. It is hard work, even for the experienced and gifted.

Friday, August 24, 2012

Signatures of an exotic Mott insulator

There is a really nice preprint Power-law dependence of the optical conductivity observed in the quantum spin-liquid compound κ-(BEDT-TTF)2Cu2(CN)3
by Sebastian Elsasser, Dan Wu, Martin Dressel, John A. Schlueter

The simplest possible picture of charge excitations in a Mott insulator is that it is similar to a band insulator but the origin of the gap is from correlations. Then one expects that

1. There is a non-zero charge gap.
2. The same energy gap occurs in the dc conductivity (activation energy) and the optical conductivity.
3. At finite temperature the subgap absorption in the optical conductivity arises due to thermal excitations across the energy gap. Hence, the subgap absorption decreases with decreasing temperature.

Indeed such behaviour is observed in the organic Mott insulator kappa-(BEDT-TTF)2Cu(NCN)2Cl which has an antiferromagnetic ground state [denoted kappa-Cl below].

However, this preprint reports qualitatively different behaviour in the title compound [denoted kappa-CN below]. Specifically,
A. There is activated behaviour in the dc conductivity.
B. Power law behaviour occurs in the optical conductivity, from about 20 to 1000 cm-1.
C. This "subgap" absorption increases in intensity with decreasing temperature.

Motivated by earlier, but less detailed, measurements showing similar results, Tai-Kai Ng and Patrick Lee, developed a theory which captures some of these properties. The key physics is the following. In the spin liquid state the elementary excitations are spinons which are charge neutral [and have a Fermi surface] and U(1) internal gauge fields associated with spin chirality fluctuations. An external electromagnetic field couples to the gapless spinon excitations indirectly via the internal gauge field. This produces the low frequency absorption.

A couple of cautionary caveats:

a. the experiment does require subtracting off a background signal associated with molecular vibrations, but that does appear robust to me.

b. the observed power law exponent is smaller than predicted by Ng and Lee.
However, doing reliable theory in this regime is so challenging, requiring uncontrolled approximations, I think it is unrealistic to expect this theory to get all the details right.

I thank Martin Dressel for bringing this work to my attention.

Wednesday, August 22, 2012

Understanding plagiarism by non-Western students

Undergraduate students from Western countries commit plagiarism. This has led to highly effective commercial software to detect it such as Turnitin.

Recently I have encountered several incidents of plagiarism from postgraduate students from non-Western countries. It is easy to be shocked and morally indignant about this, until one learns some of the cultural background and common educational practices in some countries. The following is helpful:
T. A. Abinandanan, an engineer at the Indian Institute of Science, says that the practice of duplicating information is deeply ingrained in Indian education. “Right from school our students are encouraged to take material from books and websites and use it in their charts and lab notebooks. In written answers, verbatim reproduction from textbooks is even rewarded with higher marks,” he told Nature. “Thus, when students start doing research, they have so much of this attitude to unlearn. This unfortunate case provides us yet another opportunity to redouble our efforts in training our students.”
This is taken from a News item that appeared in Nature earlier this year.

A key to stopping is this is education, central documentation of incidents, and strictly enforced penalties that increase substantially for repeat offenders.

Tuesday, August 21, 2012

Twisting fluorescent proteins

Seth Olsen and I just finished a paper A two-state model of twisted intramolecular charge transfer in monomethine dyes.
It presents a simple characterisation the ground and excited state potential energy surfaces associated with bond twisting of the chromophore for the green fluorescent protein. This is based on a 2 x 2 matrix Hamiltonian acting on diabatic states which have a simple valence bond interpretation.

Saturday, August 18, 2012

In praise of publons

A publon is a "quantum" of publication. It is the least publishable unit of research.

I have found this to be a very helpful concept in doing and supervising research and deciding what and when to publish. The basic idea is that once you have a result that is publishable [a new equation or measurement or graph or numerical result] for a specific research project one should start to prepare a paper around it. Large projects can be broken down into publons. I first really took on board the concept after reading Peter Feibelman's A Ph.D is not enough. 

The advantages are

-research and publication can much more manageable

-it avoids procrastination, particularly by perfectionists who always want to get one more result...

-it placates the "bean counters" who expect quick results and large numbers of papers

-papers should have a single message and not several. publons prevent that single message being diluted or distracted from

-it can be helpful in building confidence and momentum in new situations: a new project, a new institution, a new position, a new student, or a new postdoc....

The disadvantages/dangers are

-results are published too quickly before they have been checked, compared to other methods, or for other systems.

-peoples publication list becomes inflated.

-too many short and superficial papers are published

-it is pandering to the "bean counters".

Friday, August 17, 2012

Talk in Bangalore on overdoped cuprates

Today I had a nice visit to the Physics Department at Indian Institute of Science. My host was Subroto Mukherjee. I gave a talk Interlayer magnetoresistance as a probe of Fermi surface anisotropies in overdoped cuprates. It was nice to get so many questions during the talk.

The more recent results are in a PRB written with Jure Kokalj and Nigel Hussey.


Monday, August 13, 2012

Talk on methine dyes at IISc

Tomorrow I am visiting the Solid State and Structural Chemistry Unit at the Indian Institute of Science in Bangalore. My host in Ramasesha. I will give a talk [slides] about effective Hamiltonians for the excited electronic states of methine dyes (including the chromophore for the Green Fluorescent Protein). All of this work was done largely by Seth Olsen.
A good introduction and overview is our recent J. Chem. Phys. paper.

Emergence and centralised planning of scientific research

 Scientists, individually and collectively, make decisions about research directions and priorities. There are three main interacting influe...