Some amazing things about the universe that make science possible

 This post takes off from the following Einstein quotes.

"The most incomprehensible thing about the universe is that it is comprehensible"

from "Physics and Reality"(1936), in Ideas and Opinions, trans. Sonja Bargmann (New York: Bonanza, 1954), p292.

"...I consider the comprehensibility of the world (to the extent that we are authorized to speak of such a comprehensibility) as a miracle or as an eternal mystery. Well, a priori, one should expect a chaotic world, which cannot be grasped by the mind in any way .. the kind of order created by Newton's theory of gravitation, for example, is wholly different." 

Letters to Solovine, New York, Philosophical Library, 1987, p 131.

There are several dimensions to the comprehensibility of the universe. The dimension highlighted by Einstein is that there is order in the world, reflected in laws that can be succinctly stated and mathematically encoded. These laws seem to hold for all time and everywhere in the universe. Here I suggest there are three other dimensions that make science possible. 

A second amazing dimension is that humans have the rational ability to do science: to reason, to understand, to communicate, and to make instruments such as telescopes and microscopes. There seems to be somewhat of a match between the rationality of the universe and human rationality. This is written in the spirit of arguments about fine-tuning, where one imagines alternative universes.

Humans could have been different. Suppose that the amount and variation of human intelligence (at least that aspect of intelligence relevant to doing science) were different, and the mean and standard deviation were lower. Suppose that intelligence was lower so that there were no brilliant humans like Darwin, Einstein, Newton, Pauling, ... In fact, suppose that even the brightest people were as good at science as I am at music and dancing. Scientific progress would be rather limited.

But it is not just human intelligence that matters. A third amazing dimension is that of manual dexterity. I am "all thumbs" and not particularly good in the lab. There are some gifted experimentalists with an outstanding ability to do things most people cannot, even with training. Such abilities allow them to fabricate precision instruments, grow crystals, see faint images, ... If some humans did not have such abilities scientific progress would have been much slower, or possibly non-existent.

A fourth crucial dimension concerns the availability and processability of certain materials that are central to scientific progress. Making instruments requires particular materials such as metals, glass, and semiconductors. Suppose we lived in a world where some of these were very rare or just could not be processed to the purity or malleability required.