Friday, December 27, 2019

Question your intuitions and preconceptions

 My economist son often listens to the podcast, Conversations with Tyler Cohen. We recently listened to a conversation with Esther Duflo, who shared the 2019 Nobel Prize in Economics. Like most episodes it covers a wide range of territory, from development economics to Indian classical music to parenting. I highly recommend it.

Perhaps, the bit that was most striking for me was the following.
What advice do you give to your talented undergraduates that differs from the advice your colleagues would give them?  
I give almost all of them the advice to take some time off, in particular if they have any interest in development, which is generally the reason why they come to see me in the first place. But even if they don’t really, to spend a year or two in a developing country, working on a project. Not necessarily inner city. Any project spending time in the field.  
It’s only through this exposure that you can learn how wrong most of your intuitions are and preconceptions are. I can tell it to them till they are blue in the face to not let themselves be guided by what seems obvious to them. But until they’ve confronted what they think is obvious to something entirely different, then it’s not clear.
I think this relates to profound differences (cultural and economic and experiential) between rich countries and Majority World countries. Culture is what you assume is normal and unquestioned.

1 comment:

  1. Nobel minds 2019 moderated discussion.

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=h-QdXzOboWk

    There is a big difference between social sciences and scientists answering the moderators questions. Economics is surely part of social sciences. The way the three economists discuss in the the utube , ease of collaboration between them and the NLs in medicine saying we compete with each other reflects the hyperactive nature of doing science. Towards the end Prof Peeble's NL in physics asks about water vapor. This question is an excellent question. However the medicine NL reaction is very hyper , almost dubbing Prof Pebbles as an heretic. Just watch economists ducking with a smile at this " Heretic " word. The moderator is also amused at this. Water vapor and its effect as a greenhouse has on Gulf stream has been rightly raised by Prof Pebbles.

    One feels scientists have a lot to learn from social scientists when it comes to human interactive skills.

    ReplyDelete

A very effective Hamiltonian in nuclear physics

Atomic nuclei are complex quantum many-body systems. Effective theories have helped provide a better understanding of them. The best-known a...