Friday, May 13, 2016

The power of simple free energy arguments

I love the phase diagram below and like to show it to students because it is so cute.


However, in terms of understanding, I always found it a bit bamboozling.

On monday I am giving a lecture on phase transformations of mixtures, closely following the nice textbook by Schroeder, Section 5.4.

Such a phase diagram is quite common.
Below is the phase diagram for the liquid-solid transition in mixtures of tin and lead.

Having prepared the lecture, I now understand the physical origin of these diagrams.

Eutectic [greek for easy melting] point is the lowest temperature at which the liquid is stable.

What is amazing is that one can understand these diagrams from simple arguments based on a very simple and physically motivated functional form for the Gibbs free energy that includes the entropy of mixing.
It is of the form

G(x) = C + D x + E x(1-x) + T [xlnx + (1-x)ln(1-x)]

where x is the mole fraction of the one substance in the mixture and T is the temperature.
The parameters C, D, and E are constants for a particular state.

The second term represents the free energy difference between pure A and pure B.
The third term represents the energy difference between A-B interactions and the average of A-A and B-B interactions. [I am not sure this is completely necessary].
The crucial last term represents the entropy of mixing (for ideal solutions).

Below one compares the G(x) curves for the three states: alpha (solid mixture with alpha crystal structure), beta, and liquid in order to construct the phase diagram.


2 comments:

  1. Regarding " The third term represents the energy difference between A-B interactions and the average of A-A and B-B interactions. [I am not sure this is completely necessary", this term is, in fact, vital. Entropy will always favour complete mixing. What inhibits mixing is the cost of having interfaces between A and B components. This balance leads to phase separation and a well-defined surface tension between the phases.

    ReplyDelete

Quantum states of matter and metrology

Two characteristics of states of matter are associated with them being referred to as quantum. One characteristic is the importance of quant...