I was pleased to see that the Chemistry prize was awarded to Dan Shechtman for the discovery of quasi-periodic materials that led to a new definition of crystal (quasi-crystals). Back in 2003 APS News published a nice discussion of the background to the paper which appeared in PRL in 1984 and is the 8th most cited PRL of all time.
An earlier post discusses why I teach undergraduates about quasi-crystals. It illustrates the fundamental logical principle that A implies B does not mean that B implies A. Specifically, just because a periodic arrangement of atoms is a sufficient condition for a discrete X-ray pattern does not mean that it is a necessary condition. It also shows students that what they read in textbooks may be wrong.
Shechtman is not the first condensed matter physicist to be awarded the Nobel Prize in chemistry. Other recent examples include Walter Kohn and Alan Heeger.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Elastic frustration in molecular crystals
Crystals of large molecules exhibit diverse structures. In other words, the geometric arrangements of the molecules relative to one another ...

-
Is it something to do with breakdown of the Born-Oppenheimer approximation? In molecular spectroscopy you occasionally hear this term thro...
-
Nitrogen fluoride (NF) seems like a very simple molecule and you would think it would very well understood, particularly as it is small enou...
-
Attempts to develop a quantum theory of gravity continue to falter and stagnate. Given this, it is worth considering approaches that start w...
I think the periodic arrangement is sufficient, but not necessary!
ReplyDeleteYou are correct!
ReplyDeleteI have changed it.