This is the title of section 1.4 in Phil Nelson's book, Biological Physics.
I really like the way he uses subsection titles which convey useful information. Here are some:
1.4.1 Most physical quantities carry dimensions
1.4.2 Dimensional analysis can help you catch errors and recall definitions
1.4.3 Dimensional analysis can also help you formulate hypotheses
I think something that we just have to keep "hammering" students on is keeping track of units at each step of a calculation and canceling them out.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Elastic interactions and complex patterns in binary systems
One of the many beauties of condensed matter physics is that it can reveal and illuminate how two systems or phenomena that at first appear ...
-
This week Nobel Prizes will be announced. I have not done predictions since 2020 . This is a fun exercise. It is also good to reflect on w... -
Is it something to do with breakdown of the Born-Oppenheimer approximation? In molecular spectroscopy you occasionally hear this term thro... -
Nitrogen fluoride (NF) seems like a very simple molecule and you would think it would very well understood, particularly as it is small enou...
I agree in principal, but the way it is done now (or at least, when I went through) does not emphasise why keeping track of dimensions is useful. It wasn't until I started tutoring first years that I 'discovered' how useful it can be.
ReplyDeleteIn my intro courses, I give the example of forgetting to copy down the square when calculating kinetic energy, say with m = 5.0 kg and v = 2 m/s:
ReplyDeleteK = 1/2 m v^2
= 1/2 * (5.0) * (2)
= 5.0
If the mistaken student had kept track of his units in the second line, he'd have seen that his answer came out to kg*m/s, not kg*m^2/s^2 = Joules. (Granted, most of them still don't listen.)
I do find it difficult, however, to require students to keep track of units when it comes to E&M, since the units are less "physically intuitive."