It seems to me many authors (particularly non-experts) are rather sloppy when they refer to electronic structure calculations based on Density Functional Theory (DFT). They say things like "our results are in good agreement with DFT calculations" or "we calculate the excited state energies using DFT". What don't I like about this?
DFT is an exact theory,.... provided one has the exact exchange-correlation functional and one can solve the non-linear variational functional equation the density must satisfy....
Hence, DFT should always agree with experiment!
But in reality, pure DFT is practically useless. One cannot do either of the above and so much use approximate functionals such as those based on the Local Density Approximation (LDA) or Generalised Gradient Approximation (GGA). These then lead to Kohn-Sham type equations which are straight-forward to solve.
Hence, it seems to me it is preferable to say, "our experimental results are comparable to values obtained from DFT-based calculations using the LDA".
But, maybe I am just pedantic...
Wednesday, March 14, 2012
Tuesday, March 13, 2012
Polywater: lest we forget
Many readers may be unaware of an embarrassing period in the history of physical chemistry and quantum chemistry [and Science, Nature, and DARPA]. (I only know about it because I grew up hearing my father talk about it). For a few heady years around 1970, many scientists sincerely believed that there was a stable polymer form of water. This was even "supported" by quantum chemistry calculations by Allen and Kollman (Princeton University) published in Science.
Eventually, it turned out that the original experimental evidence for polywater resulted from impurities.
This sad episode is recounted in detail in the book Polywater by Felix Franks. There is a very nice review by David Eisenberg, entitled "A Scientific Gold Rush" (published in Science!) of the book. It is worth reading, including the discussion of how the fact that the existence of polywater would have violated the laws of thermodynamics did not deter many true believers...
Here is a quote from the review:
Eventually, it turned out that the original experimental evidence for polywater resulted from impurities.
This sad episode is recounted in detail in the book Polywater by Felix Franks. There is a very nice review by David Eisenberg, entitled "A Scientific Gold Rush" (published in Science!) of the book. It is worth reading, including the discussion of how the fact that the existence of polywater would have violated the laws of thermodynamics did not deter many true believers...
Here is a quote from the review:
[Franks] is interested in the factors, partly nonscientific, that created the gold rush atmosphere and distorted the normal scientific process. Among the factors blamed by Franks are:
the willingness of some scientists to submit for publication incomplete or even shoddy work in order to achieve priority;
a breakdown in normal standards of reviewing, particularly in journals such as Nature and Science that publish short notes on matters perceived to be of wide current interest;
a concern among administrators in defense-sponsored research agencies that in the post-Sputnik era it would be unfortunate to allow the Soviets the lead in another field;
a fascination on the part of the public, created in part by exaggerated and inaccurate reports in the popular press, with a new form of water;
a tendency of investigators to leak results to the press before publication;It is fascinating and noteworthy that JACS only published one paper on polywater. Somehow some of the factors above remind me of "quantum biology" today...
Monday, March 12, 2012
Seeing the dark state in fluorescent proteins
Two years ago Seth Olsen and I published a paper, pointing out that in the Green Fluorescent Protein there should be a dark excited state [i.e. a state which does not contribute significantly to the one-photon absorption cross section] which should have a large two photon absorption (TPA) cross section. This has a natural explanation in terms of a valence bond description of the three lowest lying singlet states of the chromophore.
We were very pleased that last year there was a long article in Nature methods, Two-photon absorption properties of fluorescent proteins, by Drobizhev et al.. It contains the data below. The peak on the left (around 650 nm) is due to TPA from the dark excited state.
The authors were unaware of our work, but cite it in their latest paper on vibronic effects in two-photon absorption.
We were very pleased that last year there was a long article in Nature methods, Two-photon absorption properties of fluorescent proteins, by Drobizhev et al.. It contains the data below. The peak on the left (around 650 nm) is due to TPA from the dark excited state.
The authors were unaware of our work, but cite it in their latest paper on vibronic effects in two-photon absorption.
An inspirational chemist is inspired by chemistry
CNR Rao has published an auto-biography Climbing the Limitless Ladder: A Life in Chemistry. There are nice reviews in the Hindu newspaper and Chemistry World. It is impressive how he continues to be so passionate about doing science, in spite of many successes and the burden of significant administrative and advising responsibilities.
Friday, March 9, 2012
Testing universality in ultracold fermion atomic gases
Today we had a nice colloquium by Chris Vale about recent experiments from his group testing Tan's universal relations for ultracold high density (k_F a much greater than 1) atomic Fermi gases with large scattering lengths a.
This regime corresponds to the centre of the figure below, taken from a Physics Today article by Carlos Sa de Melo
There is an interesting short Physics article by Eric Braaten which puts Tan's theory in a broader historical context.
This regime corresponds to the centre of the figure below, taken from a Physics Today article by Carlos Sa de Melo
There is an interesting short Physics article by Eric Braaten which puts Tan's theory in a broader historical context.
"in preparation" is not a publication
On your CV you need to clearly distinguish real publications, preprints, and works "in preparation".
When reviewing CV's I personally think the latter are just irritating, count for nothing, and should be left off your CV.
When reviewing CV's I personally think the latter are just irritating, count for nothing, and should be left off your CV.
Thursday, March 8, 2012
The value of course blogs
For the fourth semester I am teaching a course with a blog where students must write weekly on the blog about what they are learning. They also must write some comments on other student posts.
I think this is a very valuable experience for the students and for me. It keeps them engaged and forces them to think about what they are learning. I find it very valuable to read their posts because it gives me a good measure of their level of understanding and what topics or concepts they are struggling with. I am usually struck by how much they still need to learn and understand, and how things that seem obvious to me are not to them. It is a good reminder how about 25 years ago I struggled to master the subject too. I need to slow down my teaching and explain everything carefully. You can check out the blog here.
I think this is a very valuable experience for the students and for me. It keeps them engaged and forces them to think about what they are learning. I find it very valuable to read their posts because it gives me a good measure of their level of understanding and what topics or concepts they are struggling with. I am usually struck by how much they still need to learn and understand, and how things that seem obvious to me are not to them. It is a good reminder how about 25 years ago I struggled to master the subject too. I need to slow down my teaching and explain everything carefully. You can check out the blog here.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
What criteria should be used to evaluate theories of emergence properties?
What criteria do people use to decide if a theory in physics is successful? For special relativity, general relativity, and quantum theory, ...
-
An interesting and controversial question for Ph.D's in science and engineering is too what extent students should be expected to have ...
-
Some of my colleagues and I have started an interesting discussion about how to teach quantum theory to undergraduates. We have courses in t...
-
As years go by the PhD thesis in science and engineering is less and less of a ``thesis'' and more just a box to tick. There was a t...


