Tuesday, March 6, 2012

Capturing the directionality of hydrogen bonding

Below is a schematic picture of hydrogen bonding between a donor D and an acceptor A.
An interesting and important question is how the potential energy of the system varies with the angle phi which measures deviations from linearity. A key property of H-bonds is that they are highly directional. This leads to the four-fold co-ordination of water in liquid and solid phases.

There is a vibrational mode associated with this co-ordinate phi.
[In water this rotation is connected to the librational mode].

Previously I posted about an empirical correlation showing how this mode hardens with the increasing strength of the H-bond (decreasing R above). This is the opposite trend to the D-H stretch frequency (associated with the r co-ordinate above) which softens with decreasing R.

I was very pleased when I discovered that the model effective Hamiltonian I proposed for H-bonding can describe this correlation (see the figure below) without introducing any new parameters.
This is discussed in more detail in the final version of my paper.

Aside: I earlier posted the graph above in a post about confirmation bias. I should say that after I did get good agreement between the theory and experiment, I did go back and check all the algebra and mathematica codes.

The beauty of the Drude model

I have been teaching the Drude model for the umpteenth time, but have a new slant I am emphasizing to the students. It only involves a single new parameter, the scattering time. Yet it is able to capture the details of a wide range of experiments on elemental metals. I think it is important for students to appreciate the importance of considering the simplest possible models, with as few free parameters as possible, and see what they can and cannot explain. Only then one should move to more advanced models which are closer to the "truth".

Monday, March 5, 2012

The age-old problem of management

Chelsea football club announced on the weekend that they are sacking their manager Andre Villas-Boas (AVB) after less than 12 months on the job.

Why is this relevant? In the midst of all the analysis one point was clear. One of the problems was that AVB was only 34 years old and was managing players who were only two years younger than him.

Sometimes this is a problem in academia. I have known of very successful young faculty members who have struggled to gain the respect needed for a good working relationship from students or postdocs who are older than them. This is a complex issue (because people are complex!). There are counter examples and every case is different but it is something to be cautious about. If you are a young faculty member think twice before you hire an older person and if you are an older student make sure you really do respect your potential advisor before you sign on.

Saturday, March 3, 2012

What is wrong with this textbook?

It contains no actual experimental data. Just schematic representations of data or functional relationships.
Or, it contains "artist renditions" of data. Below is an example from Atkins' Physical Chemistry.

The best texts show actual data. Two of my favourite texts are: Biological Physics by Phil Nelson and An Introduction to Thermal Physics by Daniel Schroeder.

It is also interesting and disturbing that looking through the Australian edition of a popular introductory microeconomics text co-authored by Robert E. Frank [of Economic Naturalist fame] I could only find schematic graphs and no actual data.

Why does this matter?
After all, the figures look so much nicer and cleaner if they are just schematic. It is easier for students to understand them.

However, I think it is very important that students learn:
  • Real science is messy.
  • A theory is only as good as the experimental evidence for it.
  • How to read, understand, and critique experimental data.
Below is a very nice figure from Kittel's Introduction to Solid State Physics. It shows the magnetic susceptibility of different elemental metals. Looking at the data gives a sense of how reliable is the prediction of the Sommerfeld (and Bloch) models that the susceptibility is independent of temperature for temperatures much less than the Fermi temperature. Unfortunately, my preferred text by Ashcroft and Mermin does not show such a graph.

Friday, March 2, 2012

Deconstructing Kondo universality

At the cake meeting this week I gave a talk on Nozieres' classic 1974 paper, A "Fermi liquid" description of the Kondo Problem at low temperatures. He gives a very elegant (but hard to follow) argument as to why the Wilson ratio should have the universal value 2, independent of the strength of the Kondo coupling J.

There is actually a clearer restatement of Nozieres' argument in a review article by Piers Coleman (see section 2.6). [I thank Ben Powell for pointing this out]. Hewson's book (Section 5.1) also has an equivalent argument but I found that even harder to follow. But, I did like the connection to Friedel's sum rule and the emphasis that the charge compressibility on the impurity site is zero.

Key assumptions (and physical insights) required in the argument seem to be:
  • A Fermi liquid fixed point (J=infinity).
  • An analytic dependence of the phase shift on energy.
  • The Kondo singlet acts as a spinless, elastic scattering centre with phase shift pi/2 at the Fermi energy.
  • The Kondo-Suhl resonance is pinned to the chemical potential.
  • For quasi-particles away from the Fermi energy only interact with quasi-particles of opposite spin.

Thursday, March 1, 2012

Why is the theory of strongly correlated electrons so challenging?

The field is particularly demanding due to the need to assess, integrate and synthesize large amounts of information from a diverse range of experimental, theoretical, and computational studies that use a plethora of techniques to study a multitude of properties, models, and materials. This requires significant amounts of time and experience to evaluate and make appropriate judgement calls about the relative importance and probable validity of specific pieces of information. Inadequately informed judgements can lead to wasted time due to pursuing directions that ultimately turn out to be at best irrelevant and at worst wrong.

Furthermore, an intimate knowledge of both the chemical and physical properties of solids is a necessary ingredient for the development of realistic models of different classes of complex materials. A key judgement has to be made about how much detail is necessary.

Or, is the field a mine field?

What criteria should be used to evaluate theories of emergence properties?

What criteria do people use to decide if a theory in physics is successful? For special relativity, general relativity, and quantum theory, ...