Monday, October 29, 2012

d-wave pairing in superconducting organics


We now have significance experimental evidence which should end any debate about whether the superconductivity in organic charge transfer salts is unconventional.

There is a nice preprint
In-plane superfluid density and microwave conductivity of the organic superconductor κ-(BEDT-TTF)2Cu[N(CN)2]Br: evidence for d-wave pairing
S. Milbradt, A. A. Bardin, C. J. S. Truncik, W. A. Huttema, P. L. Burn, S.-C. Lo, B. J. Powell, D. M. Broun

They provide definitive measurements of the temperature dependence of the superfluid density and of the quasi-particle scattering rate. What is distinctly new and exciting about these very careful and precise measurements is the absolute determination of these quantities.

The results also highlight some of the similarities of the organics with the cuprates: a d-wave superconductor "derived" from an antiferromagnetic Mott insulator and that quasi-particle scattering is largely due to electron-electron interactions. Indeed, the key temperature dependences shown below are essentially the same as what is seen in the cuprates.
There are three clear experimental signatures of d-wave pairing:
  • the linear temperature dependence of the superfluid density (see figure above)
  • the T^3 dependence of the scattering rate in the superconducting state
  • the absence of a BCS "coherence" peak in the conductivity near Tc
I particularly like the figure below. It shows how the quasi-particle scattering rate drops dramatically in the superconducting state because the electronic degrees of freedom  responsible for the scattering are being "gapped out" by the superconductivity.

Saturday, October 27, 2012

Is open access comical?

There is a video clearly explaining the case for Open Access to research journals. It is illustrated by Ph.D comics. I thank Tony Wright for bringing it to my attention.



A previous post The insatiable greed of commercial journals discussed some of relevant political background in the USA.

To curtail the influence the role of commercial journals, I think the least we can do is aim to mostly publish in journals run by professional societies such as American Physical Society and the American Chemical Society.

I also think research groups should be putting their "raw" research data sets online so others can analyse them independently.

I welcome comments.

Friday, October 26, 2012

The quality of agreement and comparisons

Many authors like to make statements such as "our calculated value of 1.23 for X is in excellent agreement with the experimental value of 2 for X".

In contrast, this week I read the modest statement "the DMFT value of 0.66 is in mediocre agreement with the Brinkman-Rice value of 0.47" in this review [below eqn. (266)].

I think the quality of agreement in such comparisons is in the eye of the beholder. Different people can have quite different standards. Furthermore, the level of agreement one might hope for depends strongly on the context and many other factors. e.g., how many free parameters there are, how difficult it is to calculate or measure the relevant quantity, and how sensitive the calculated quantity is to the level of theory.

Let me illustrate with two statements a hypothetical author might write in the future:

1.
"my new formulation of renormalisation in quantum electrodynamics (QED) leads to value for the g-factor of the electron that agrees with experiment to one part in a thousand"

2.
"my new quantum field theory of gravity leads to a value of the cosmological constant which differs from the observed value by a factor of one hundred."

To the novice, 1. sounds very impressive and 2. sounds lame.
However, paper 1. would be ignored and paper 2. may lead to a Nobel Prize!
Why?
Existing versions of renormalisation in QED give values of g that agree with experiment to about 15 significant figures!
Existing formulations of the cosmological constant in quantum field theory give values that differ from experiment by about 100 orders of magnitude!
[Weinberg has a nice looking review on this that I hope to read sometime....]

The solution to this problem?
I think we should simply write: "our calculated value of 1.23 for X can be compared with the experimental value of 2 for X".
Let the reader decide for themselves whether they think the "agreement" is excellent, impressive, surprising, disappointing, mediocre, poor, .....

Thursday, October 25, 2012

Searching for the nodes in an unconventional superconductor

In the cuprate high-Tc superconductors it is now well established experimentally that the superconductivity has d_x^2-y^2 symmetry with nodes in the energy gap along the Brillouin zone diagonals. This is what is predicted by spin fluctuation and RVB theories.

In the organic charge transfer salts the experimental situation is not as clear. There are clear theoretical predictions of unconventional superconductivity with nodes in the gap.
Hence, I was interested to read the paper:

Location of gap nodes in the organic superconductors kappa-(ET)2Cu(NCS)2 and kappa-(ET)2Cu[N(CN)2]Br determined by magnetocalorimetry
L. Malone, O.J. Taylor, J.A. Schlueter, and A. Carrington

This experiment is difficult [measuring the specific heat at low temperatures while rotating a magnetic field within the layers] and its interpretation is subtle. The conclusion is that the nodes are as shown below. This is where they are predicted to be by both spin fluctuation and RVB theory. (A nice article by Ben Powell discusses the relevant theory).
The authors (helpfully and honestly) point out that these results are inconsistent with some thermal conductivity measurements. 
However, Tony Carrington pointed out to me:

The point is that the results could be consistent if they are in different parts of the B/T phase diagram.  The problem is that in both thermal conductivity and specfic heat measurements the sign of the oscillations changes as a function of B and T.  In the low B, low T limit both give a maximum when B is in the antinodal direction, but this becomes a maximum at higher T and higher B.  For thermal conductivity this occurs at a different temperature compared to the specific heat (according to Vekhter's model).  So both could be consistent with the same nodal structure.

Something that would be particularly interesting would be to do similar measurements on  a different organic charge transfer described in an earlier post because RVB theory predicts the nodes would be in a different location.

Wednesday, October 24, 2012

How many authors is too many?

Physics Today recently published an excellent commentary Too Many authors, two few creators by Philip Wyatt. It is worth reading in full.

He compares the number of authors per paper in 8 major journals in 1965 and 2011. The number of single authors has plummeted while the number of papers with 4+ authors has dramatically increased.
In contrast, the number of authors of patent applications has remained steady.
Wyatt argues that this reflects a decrease in creativity. This is all caused by the pressure for everyone to have large numbers of publications and citations to survive in science.
He asserts that many authors have not made significant scientific contributions to a paper and so should only be in the acknowledgements section.
He sings the praises of single author papers, as I do.

Why has not the number of authors on patent applications increased?
If a listed inventor, or “innovator,” did not actually contribute to the invention, the issued patent will be void if such deception is ever discovered. The patents most easily challenged in court may well be those with extraordinary numbers of inventors.
Overall I agree with Wyatt's concerns.
Some people are getting credit they don't deserve.
Multiple authors make it very hard to evaluate the quality and quantity of individuals contributions.
Too much time is being wasted producing papers as opposed to doing creative and productive science of lasting value.

The commentary brought a number of interesting responses. I particularly agreed with his  response included the statement:
so much effort seems focused on writing papers just to secure funding or a job that many fundamental building blocks needed as tools to spur creativity in our young scientists are lost in the process.

Tuesday, October 23, 2012

What is my information diet?

Like most scientists I don't think I have a very balanced or healthy or disciplined diet. It has changed over the years, both with seniority and the internet.

I tend not to work on highly fashionable topics and so don't feel I have to look at the arXiv each day or the Table of Contents of journals. I hope (and expect) that postdocs or collaborators will bring to my attention particularly noteworthy recent papers or articles. I greatly appreciate it when they do. Colleagues also kindly send me some their recent work that they think may be of interest. I appreciate this and unlike some do not begrudge it as shameless self-promotion. On the other hand I don't appreciate being sent stuff which is of marginal or no relevance.

A lot of stuff I need I find with Google Scholar using carefully chosen word searches.

About 15 years ago, I believe I once heard Doug Stone claim that one thing he learnt from Patrick Lee was that he did not need to keep up with journals. Why? If there was some new important development he needed to know about someone would come through his office door and tell him about it.
I don't rate myself in this class. But it is an insight into how some high-profile people operate.

I only go to a couple of conferences per year. I also visit a few departments each year and talk with colleagues individually about what they are working on. These are a good way to catch up.

What is a balanced diet?
I am not sure.
One has to balance Nature/Science and PRL and PRB and others.
One also has to balance theory and experiment.
Furthermore, some of us have to balance chemistry and physics.
One also has to balance papers of broad interest, reviews, foundational references, and latest results.

In general I spend too much time downloading, printing and not reading. I also probably read too much chemistry and experiment, rather than theory. On the other hand, some of my past main successes have been built on that focus.
I also probably read too many papers superficially rather than properly understanding a few.

For the last year, I have been getting the weekly update from Science. But, the main reason is not to find out which condensed matter physics group got a paper in! Rather, I try to read some of the summaries of the biology, ecology, climate change, geology, chemistry, and psychology papers. I usually struggle to understand but it is a nice intellectual challenge. I hope to learn just a couple of basic things...

I thank Ted Sanders for suggesting this post.
If it seems a bit rambling it is because I don't really have a handle on this issue.

I welcome suggestions and ideas, from both junior and senior people, on how they manage this problem.

Monday, October 22, 2012

Significance of the Kondo paradigm

This week we am part of new reading group which aims to work through Hewson's beautiful book The Kondo Problem to Heavy Fermions.
Why the choice of this topic?
Is it only of interest and relevance to people working on the Kondo physics and/or heavy fermion compounds?
I would say definitely no!

The Kondo problem represents a very important paradigm in quantum many-body physics. Perhaps the other main (well established and accepted) paradigms are
  • Fermi liquid theory,
  • BCS theory of superconductivity,
  • Mott insulators, 
  • spontaneous symmetry breaking
  • quantum antiferromagnets (Heisenberg models and Anderson superexchange),
  • Fractional Quantum Hall effect
Asides:
1. Perhaps Mott insulators should not be on the list because there is no well-accepted theory beyond the "zeroth-order approximation".
2. Two other paradigms that I believe will eventually be accepted are Dynamical Mean-Field Theory and the RVB theory for superconductivity in proximity to a Mott insulator.
3. Is the shortness of the list a reflection of our success or failure? Is there a need for only a few paradigms or is it just we have solved so few problems?

Furthermore, the Kondo model/problem exhibits rich physics and key concepts in quantum many-body theory including
  • non-perturbative effects
  • asymptotic freedom: weak coupling scales to strong coupling as the temperature/energy decreases
  • scaling and universality [a single energy scale: the Kondo temperature]
  • the only (?) well-established realisation of a non-Fermi liquid fixed point [in multi-channel problems]
  • a simple physically transparent variational wave function [Yosida]

It is a benchmark for testing numerical and analytical methods since it can be solved exactly analytically using the Bethe ansatz and numerically using the Numerical Renormalisation Group. Its fixed points can be described by boundary conformal field theory.

Furthermore, Kondo physics is at the heart of the Dynamical Mean-Field Theory (DMFT) treatment of the Mott metal-insulator transition and electronic structure methods (e.g. DMFT+LDA).

Finally, Nozieres says the Kondo effect "is typical of what real theory should be, using tortuous roads towards simple final results".

I welcome additions and subtractions to my lists.

Emergence and centralised planning of scientific research

 Scientists, individually and collectively, make decisions about research directions and priorities. There are three main interacting influe...