Wednesday, October 10, 2012

Physics Nobel highlights high value of table-top science

I really like the award of the 2012 Physics Nobel Prize to Serge Haroche and David Wineland. (I predicted entanglement but not these individuals).
Their studies have made theoretical ideas about quantum decoherence and entanglement actually testable in the lab. A nice summary of the scientific background is here.

One thing the award highlights to me is the high value (return on investment) of table-top science. I would guess that Haroche and Wineland's annual research budgets would be less than one million dollars.  This is to be contrasted to How much does it cost to find a Higgs boson? (about 10 billion dollars).

This award also highlights the incredible and enviable track record of NIST, who have received 4 Nobels in the past 15 years (Bill Phillips, 1997; Eric Cornell, 2001; John Hall, 2005; Phillips, 2012). The former 3 recently testified to the US congress that NIST management style was key to their success.

Table top science is relatively cheap. It is the most cost-effective investment for smaller countries and institutions.

Tuesday, October 9, 2012

An essential state model for the pseudogap state

Understanding the origin of the pseudogap state in cuprate superconductors (and organic charge transfer salts) remains a challenge. It has now been shown that within a doped Hubbard or t-J model one can produce a pseudogap like state when the model is treated at the level of the Dynamical Cluster Approximation. The DCA is a generalisation of Dynamical Mean-Field Theory (DMFT) to small clusters. Although this is a significant advance it is still somewhat at the level of a "black box". One would like to know the essential physics.

Jaime Merino and Olle Gunnarsson have a preprint which shows how a two-site two-orbital model can capture some of the essential physics. This model is motivated by DCA calculations on the smallest four site cluster. The two orbitals correspond to (0,pi) and (pi,0) in the first Brillouin zone. Each orbital couples to an independent bath.
As U increases there is a transition from the cluster orbitals forming a Kondo singlet with the bath states to formation of a non-degenerate bound state on the cluster. The latter corresponds to formation of the pseudogap.
For larger clusters the coupling to the baths are much stronger for the nodal regions than the anti-nodal regions.

The worst stage of an academic career

Last night it was announced that John Gurdon shared the 2012 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine. The Guardian website report had this interesting quote from him.
Probably the worst stage in an academic career is when starting on one's own as a new assistant professor, with a hefty load of new lectures to be prepared, the need to acquire research support for an independent program, the wish to attract students to form a group, and no one except oneself to do the lab work with which to attract students and research support. I was very fortunate to be joined, within two years of starting at this level, by two outstanding students, Christopher Graham and Ron Laskey.
"From Nuclear Transfer to Nuclear Reprogramming: The Reversal of Cell Differentiation" - J.B. Gurdon, Annual Review of Cell and Developmental Biology Vol. 22: 1-22 (Volume publication date November 2006)

Saturday, October 6, 2012

A helpful question to your audience

Does anyone have any questions so far?

If I am giving a seminar I try to ask the audience this at several points in the talk, particularly if there have been no questions so far.
Even if no one has a question is shows them you are open to them, and will keep the audience more engaged because they may make more of an effort to think of questions.

Friday, October 5, 2012

Deconstructing the Hall effect in quasi-one-dimensional metals

Understanding the Hall effect in strongly correlated electron materials is a challenge. In simple metals, the Hall coefficient R_H is, to a good approximation, equal to the inverse of the charge carrier density, and so is weakly dependent on temperature.
Furthermore, it has the same sign as the charge carriers.

In contrast, in strongly correlated metals, R_H can vary significantly with temperature, including changing sign, and its magnitude and signh can be significantly different from the charge carrier density estimated from band structure calculations or alternative experimental measurements such as the Drude weight in the optical conductivity.
I have written several previous posts about this issue. A post on the cuprates illustrates the problem.

There is a really nice paper Hall effect in quasi-one-dimensional metals in the presence of anisotropic scattering by Nicholas Wakeham and Nigel Hussey.
They show that due to the highly anisotropic band structure in a quasi-one-dimensional Fermi liquid metal, a variation of the scattering rate of just a few per cent over the Fermi surface, can significantly modify the Hall coefficient.
The figure below compares experimental data for the cuprate PrBa2Cu4O8 to a simple model with a temperature dependent anisotropy of less than 4 per cent.
The measured Hall coefficient is an order of magnitude smaller than the band structure value and changes sign twice as a function temperature.
This relatively simple explanation of complex behaviour should caution against exotic and non-Fermi liquid interpretations of Hall effect data (e.g., this PRL).

Tables are wonderful

Consider including a Table in your next paper.
They can be very useful.

For example, they can compactly summarise previous work (experimental and/or theoretical) relevant to your paper.

To me Tables highlight an important aspect of science that I think is increasingly devalued or ignored: comparison. Everyone whats to talk about their own results but is less inclined to critically compare their results to earlier work and put it in that context.

It may be painful to admit it but the Table may actually be more useful to the community than the main results in your paper.
I believe Jim Brooks once told me that this was an extremely valuable lesson he learnt from his thesis advisor Russell Donnelly.

To make this concrete I include below a Table from one of my papers with Jaime Merino.

Thursday, October 4, 2012

A limit to my understanding II

This is a follow up on a previous post which discussed the strange fact that in quantum many-body theory certain limits (e.g., zero frequency, and the long wavelength) do not necessarily commute.

Today I learnt that in 1960 Kohn and Luttinger pointed out that the following definitions of the ground state energy are not necessarily the same:

1. The lowest eigenvalue of the Hamiltonian in the thermodynamic limit.

2. The zero temperature limit of the free energy of an infinite system.

This observation was based on an examination of Goldstone's perturbation theory, which is based on 1.

Ward and Luttinger later showed that for spatially isotropic band structures and interactions the two are equivalent.
Metzner and Vollhardt [where I learned all this] claim that for the Hubbard model, to second order in U, the two are equivalent.

Aside: Kohn was very productive in the early 1960's! Another recent post referred to his seminal paper on insulators.

Emergence and centralised planning of scientific research

 Scientists, individually and collectively, make decisions about research directions and priorities. There are three main interacting influe...