Sunday, December 13, 2009

When business people think they can run a scientific organisation...

Articles from Nature, ScienceInsider, and The Age newspaper summarise recent problems concerning the strained relationship between the board (chaired by a corporate lawyer) and scientists at the Australian Synchrotron. The International scientific advisory committee has resigned in protest.

Saturday, December 12, 2009

Listening to referees

It does not take long in science to get a negative referee report that makes ones blood boil. However, as frustrating (and silly) as some reports are I think we can gain a lot by reading them carefully and reflecting on why the referee expressed the view they do.

This was brought home to me recently when within a week I had two papers outright rejected. As painful as it was to acknowledge I can now see there is some basis for some of the referees criticisms. I still claim that in both papers the science was both valid and important. However, I now see that the way the papers were written that a quick reading (which I do not begrudge since I do it too) could frustrate a referee and lead to a negative report. So I am now rewriting both papers. I think the end result will be better papers.

So, try and put your shoes in the referee [wow what a Freudian slip! ]
I mean put yourself in the shoes of the referee and see if you can see what they said and why.

Thursday, December 10, 2009

Networking with Nobel laureates


My family continues to enjoy watching the TV show The Big Bang Theory. In the episode we watched tonight Sheldon unsuccessfully tried to give Nobel Laureate George Smoot (appearing as himself) a copy of his latest paper at a conference.

Non-equilibrium Green's functions also got a mention, probably the first (and only time) in the history of prime time TV!

Wednesday, December 9, 2009

When does the wavefunction collapse in nuclear collisions?

I had some great discussions today at ANU with Cedric Simenel and David Hinde about decoherence in nuclear collisions. One of the key issues became clearer to me. Suppose a projectile nucleus in its ground state |P> collides with a target nucleus in its ground state |T>. After the collision one observes the projectile to be in state |P> with probability |a|^2 and in state |P*> with probability |b|^2.
Simple scattering theory would say that the state of the whole system is
|Psi> = a |P>|T> + b |P*>|T*>
and the reduced density matrix for P has non-zero off-diagonal terms which only disappear after the measurement is made by the detectors.

However, I suspect that if the nuclei are large enough (i.e., have enough internal degrees of freedom) then the collision itself will decohere the superposition.

So, which is the correct picture? Presumably there is a "quantum-classical" crossover as the nuclei get heavier? Are there smoking gun experiments (e.g., Mott scattering of identical particles) to distinguish the two pictures?

Tuesday, December 8, 2009

Friction in nuclear collisions

Heavy nuclei are complex quantum many-body systems with many degrees of freedom. The observation of deep inelastic collisions (DHIC) in the 1970's led to the notion of friction in nuclear physics. This concept can be used to describe the transfer of energy from the relative motion of the nuclei to the internal degrees of freedom.

I am eager to quantify this friction because it will also enable us to say something about the role of decoherence in nuclear physics.
Today at ANU, Cedric Simenel brought to my attention a recent paper that is relevant.
For several nuclear collisions the position dependent friction was recently evaluated from the
Dissipative Dynamics version of TDHF (Time-dependent Hartee-Fock) theory.

It was found the friction monotonically increases with decreasing inter-nuclear separation, with a value of about 10^{21} s^{-1} at the barrier. For the 40Ca + 40Ca reaction at a centre of mass energy of 100 MeV, about 10 MeV of energy is converted to internal excitation energy as the nuclei move beyond the barrier.
These numbers show that decoherence/friction may be important in tunneling because the dissipation rate is comparable to the barrier frequency.

Monday, December 7, 2009

In the wrong place?

This week I am in Canberra at ANU working with nuclear physicists on quantum decoherence in nuclear collisions. Discussions today inspired the previous post.

But, it is ironic that I am quoting Zurek because he is at UQ right now, and giving a seminar tomorrow.

Decoherence and irreversibility

How long does it take for Schrodingers cat to live or die?


For a quantum system interacting with an environment (containing many degrees of freedom) what causes decoherence? What sets the time scale on which it occurs?

It turns out the decoherence and dissipation are intimately connected. Decoherence arises from fluctuations in the phase of the system quantum state due to its interaction with the environment.

An important calculation was performed by Zurek in the 1980's and elegantly summarised in an expanded and updated version of his famous Physics Today article from 1991). Consider a free particle which is in a superposition state consisting of two Gaussian wave packets a distance Delta x apart.
Let gamma be the damping rate associated with friction from interaction with the environment. Then the decoherence time (i.e., the rate at which the off-diagonal parts of the density matrix decay) is given by

Thus we see that the same physics that causes friction (energy flow from the system to the environment) causes decoherence. But, they occur on completely different timescales.

Note that once Delta x is larger than the deBroglie wavelength [which it must beif we want to think about superpositions of semiclassical states] then the decoherence time is much less than the energy dissipation rate.

This connection between decoherence (fluctuations) and dissipation is another manifestation of the fluctuation-dissipation theorem.


Emergence and centralised planning of scientific research

 Scientists, individually and collectively, make decisions about research directions and priorities. There are three main interacting influe...