Sunday, December 6, 2009

Mental health issues for researchers

In my talk on academic career advice I mentioned the importance of mental health issues, which struck a chord with many. The anecdotal evidence is that this is a significant problem among people in academia at all career stages, but particularly among graduate students.

Academics (on average) tend to be highly gifted, driven, creative, critical, introspective, and sensitive. This makes them more vulnerable to mental illness, particularly depression, than the average person.

Here are just a few prominent examples, at the more extreme end of the spectrum.

John Nash (A Beautiful Mind) was a young faculty member at MIT when he was afflicted with schizophrenia. He never returned to any form of employment. In 1994, he received the Nobel Prize in Economics for work laying founds in game theory, completed in his Princeton Ph.D in mathematics.

Ludwig Boltzmann and Paul Ehrenfest both suffered from depression and committed suicide.

In 2007, the Times Higher Education Guide listed Michel Foucault as the most cited intellectual in the humanities. He suffered from severe depression as an undergraduate. He became famous for Madness and Civilization, an abridged version of Folie et déraison: Histoire de la folie à l'âge classique, which originated in his doctoral thesis.

So, protect your mental health. Here are some questionnaires to evaluate whether you are clinically depressed.

Saturday, December 5, 2009

Quantum limited detectors


Yesterday John Clarke (University of California, Berkeley) gave a nice
colloquium at UQ on Applications of SQUIDs (Superconducting Quantum Intereference Devices).

Clarke is arguably the "father" of the development of SQUIDs in both science and technology. Many of the people currently leading the development of superconducting qubits were at one time his students or postdocs. Tim Duty is to be thanked for bringing Clarke to UQ to give this fascinating talk.

The two key physical effects on which the SQUID
is based are Josephson tunneling and magnetic flux quantisation.

In a DC SQUID the I-V curve is modulated by magnetic flux, and so the device is basically a flux to voltage transducer with noise that can approach the quantum limit. They can detect magnetic fields as small as a femtotesla!

Roger Highfield's book, The Science of Harry Potter describes how the sorting hat that Harry used in the first book is based on SQUIDs. [When I told my son that, he said this is not correct because the hat is based on magic and that is the whole point!]

Clarke described two nice projects he has been involved in building highly sensitive detectors to answer fundamental questions in Cosmology.

The first involves the search for dark matter, specifically looking for clusters of galaxies, largest bound objects in the universe. This uses Sunyarev-Zeldovich effect involving shifts in the Cosmic Microwave Background because CMB photos are scattered by hot gas bound to clusters.

This invovles a Transition edge sensor which is limited by photon shot noise. 100 squid array, multiplexer, current summing circuit, comb of frequencies....
This is now installed at the South pole telescope.

The second project involves the search for cold dark matter, specifically the axion, a particle proposed in 1978 to explain the magnitude of the electric dipole moment of neutron, which is three orders of magnitude smaller than standard model predicts. [This was news to me. I thought the standard model explained everything!, more or less].

How can axions be detected? Primakoff conversion (Sikivie, 1983) of an axion to photon. I did not follow how this worked.

Noise temperature of amplifiers needs to be reduced. Want quieter ones than HEMTs (High electron mobility transistors (based on GaAs).
With SQUID noise temperature becomes about 30-40 times lower than HEMT.
Then the required measurement time decreased from 270 years to 100 days, so graduate students may be interested in working on this project!

Clarke then discussed Microtesla magnetic resonance imaging.
A standard clinical MRI machine uses 1.5 Tesla, costs 2$M, and you sometimes need to reinforce floor. Inspired by Michael Crichton novel (1999) to use earths magnetic field for imaging. [Was this tongue in cheek?]

Clarke showed results from a PNAS paper in 2004, which imaged a Red Pepper [capsicum to some?], with a resolution of 0.7mm. He also showed 3D images of arm with a field of 132 micro tesla. He went on to discuss T1 weighted contrast imaging (contrast agent is Gd salt). I then had to leave to go to my son's futsal game....

And to think that all this technology and science has come about because a young Ph.D student about 40 years ago was challenged to think about physical signatures of spontaneous symmetry breaking in superconductors....

Friday, December 4, 2009

Images of condensed matter physics

Irina Bariakhtar, webmaster for the Division of Condensed Matter Physics of the American Physical Society
has established a gallery of images that are fascinating and may be useful for talks and teaching.
Some of these images are used in a 2010 calendar.

Deconstructing charge transport in complex materials II

Following up on my previous post on impedance spectroscopy I came across two helpful reviews.
The first is a "Colloquium" article by D.L. Sidebottom in a recent Reviews of Modern Physics. It shows how in glasses which have conducting ions the rms motion of the ions can be extracted directly from the frequency dependence of the conductivity.

The second article is a tutorial review applying impedance spectroscopy to conducting polymers, especially when they are used as electrodes in biomedical applications

Thursday, December 3, 2009

Read the ad, answer the ad

If you are applying for a job:

read the advertisement very carefully and note answers to the following questions

what sort of person are they looking for?
is the job to work
-with a specific person, with a specific group, or to work independently?
- on a specific project?
- in a specific research area?

is the job supported by a specific grant or program?

After you have gleaned answers to these questions answer:
Do I want this specific job?
Would should they be specifically interested in me?

Then if you apply make sure your cover letter specifically tells them why you want THIS specific job and why they should interview specifically YOU.

Wednesday, December 2, 2009

Model Hamiltonian parameters from electronic structure theory

An important step in modelling complex materials is writing down effective Hamiltonians which capture the essential physics. One approach to estimating model parameters for a specific material is to calculate them using methods from electronic structure theory.

About ten years ago, following earlier work by Kino and Fukuyama, I wrote a review arguing that the relevant Hamiltonian for the kappa-(BEDT-TTF)2X family of superconducting organic charge transfer salts was a Hubbard model on the anisotropic triangular lattice at half filling.

A recent PRL by a group from Goethe Universitat Frankfurt is of particular interest to me because it describes state-of-the-art calculations based on density functional theory. For three different anions X and two different pressures, the authors calculate the parameters t and t' which define the band structure. Figure 4 from the paper gives a nice summary of the results.
[Similar results were obtained at the same time by a group in Japan and reported here.]

The ratio t'/t has a significant effect on the ground state of the system, as can be seen in the proposed phase diagram from a PRL by Ben Powell and I.

A few specific things that stood out to me about the results:

1. The ratio t'/t does vary significantly with anion X.

X, t'/t , experimental ground state at ambient pressure
Cu[N(CN)2]Cl, 0.44 +- 0.05, antiferromagnetic Mott insulator
Cu(SCN)2, 0.58 +- 0.05, superconductor
Cu2(CN)3, 0.83 +- 0.08, spin liquid Mott insulator

This variation can explain why one does see a "chemical pressure" effect. i.e., the anion does have a significant effect on the ground state.

2. The level of DFT used (LDA vs. GGA) does not seem to have a large effect (less than ten per cent) on the results, increasing confidence that the results are somewhat robust.

3. The calculated magnitudes of t~0.05-0.07 eV are comparable to those estimated from comparision of the experimental optical conductivity to that calculated using dynamical mean-field theory (see this PRL).

4. The values of t and t' can be used to estimate the bare density of states at the Fermi energy. Comparison with measurements of the cyclotron effective mass and the specific heat coefficient gamma provides a means to estimate the renormalisation of these by many body effects. This is discussed in great detail in this paper.

5. The value of t1 (the intradimer hopping) ~ 0.2 eV is comparable to that estimated from the intradimer transition in the optical conductivity.

6. The authors estimate U ~ 2t1, where t1 is the intradimer hopping, following what I did a decade ago. However, this is only true in the limit that 2t1 >> U0, the single molecule U. This turns out not to be justified and is discussed in this review.

7. The authors calculate that t varies by as much as 30 per cent as the pressure increases to 0.75 GPa ( 7.5 kbar). This can explain why the ground state does change with pressure (e.g., from Mott insulator to superconductor to metal). When I wrote my review a decade ago this was an unsolved problem.

8. The value for X=Cu2(CN)3 of t'/t = 0.83 +- 0.08 means in the relevant Heisenberg model that describes the spin degrees of freedom in the Mott insulator, J'/J ~0.6, a value comparable to that at which magnetic order disappears, as calculated in this paper.

One question I have is:
What is the physical basis of the chemical pressure effect?

Emergence and centralised planning of scientific research

 Scientists, individually and collectively, make decisions about research directions and priorities. There are three main interacting influe...