Are chemical isomers emergent?

In discussions of emergence, particularly in chemistry, isomers are often given as an example of an emergent phenomenon. In Anderson's original "More is Different" article, he discussed the chirality of sugar molecules as an example of symmetry breaking. More recently, isomers (and the associated concept of molecular structure) are invoked to justify contentious claims about strong emergence and downward causality.

Here, I explain what isomers are and consider whether they are emergent in the sense of novelty, i.e., they have properties that are qualitatively different from their constituents.

In a later post, I hope to address the more general and knotty problems of molecular structure and the Born-Oppenheimer approximation.

Structural isomers

These occur when a specific collection of atoms (chemical formula) can have more than one molecular structure. An example, shown below, is C3H4.

Each structure has different chemical and physical properties. Aggregates of each molecule can have different properties such as boiling and melting points.

Some isomers are more stable than others. They may be able to interconvert, but sometimes not on laboratory time scales.

From the point of view of a ground state potential energy surface, the different isomer structures correspond to different local minima on the surface.

Stereoisomers

The simplest example is HFClBr. There are two stable structures shown below. They are related by a chiral (mirror) symmetry. They differ physically in that they rotate the plane of polarisation of incident light in opposite directions. 

The isomers, known as enantiomers, have the same ground state energy. In terms of a potential energy surface, they correspond to two different minima and are separated by a high-energy barrier. In principle, the two forms can quantum-tunnel between each other.

Chemically, the two isomers differ in how they react with other chiral molecules.

Chirality is central to molecular biology. Proteins are made of amino acids, and in nature they all have the L-form. Most forms of DNA involve double helices with right-handed chirality. 

The chirality of drug molecules matters, as tragically found with thalidomide in the 1950s. 

Emergence?

The constituent components of these molecules can be viewed as electrons and atomic nuclei. Alternatively, the components could be viewed as the atoms they are made of. In both cases, the parts of the system do not have the structure and properties that the system does. The atoms, nuclei, and electrons all have spherical symmetry, whereas the molecules do not. Another argument is that since the isomers are qualitatively different from one another, at least one of them must be qualitatively different from the components. Hence, these molecular structures can be viewed as emergent.

However, this goes against the view that we generally associate emergence with systems with many interacting parts. If we take two massive particles interacting by gravity, they can form a stable orbit. Neither particle has this property, but we don't generally claim that such orbits are emergent.

[I am grateful to a commenter on an old post who pointed this out].

Isomers illustrate the diversity of forms often associated with emergence.

There are subtleties associated with the stability of enantiomers and the associated breaking of chiral symmetry. This is similar to the issue of ammonia having a stable pyramidal structure. (Also discussed by Anderson in "More is Different"). An isolated molecule in a vacuum will have no chirality. The ground state is a quantum superposition of both enantiomers. However, in the laboratory, the interaction of each molecule with its environment, such as other molecules, leads to decoherence that prevents quantum tunnelling. In that case, there are an infinite number of degrees of freedom associated with the environment, and they are crucial for the emergence of enantiomers.

How many states of matter are there?

Diamond and graphite are distinct solid states of carbon. They have qualitatively different physical properties, at both the microscopic and the macroscopic scale. Condensed matter physics is all about states of matter. In science classes at school, you were probably taught that there are only three states of matter: solid, liquid, and gas. Like other things you were told in school, this is incorrect. There are endless, unlimited, distinct states of matter. 

Consider the “liquid crystals” that are the basis of LCDs (Liquid Crystal Displays) in the screens of televisions, computers, and smartphones. How can something be both a liquid and a crystal? A liquid crystal is a distinct state of matter. Solids can be found in many different states. We have already seen that there are two different solid states of carbon: graphite and diamond. In everyday life ice means simply solid water. But there are in fact eighteen different solid states of water, depending on the temperature of the water and the pressure that is applied to the ice. In each of these eighteen states there is a unique spatial arrangement of the water molecules and there are qualitative differences in the physical properties of the different solid states. Welcome to the world of condensed matter...

Extract from Chapter 1, Condensed Matter Physics: A Very Short Introduction

Classifying objects, people, and societies requires making qualitative distinctions. One book is easy to understand, and another is hard. One person is kind, and another is mean. One society is egalitarian, and another is not. Justifying such qualitative distinctions is hard. Not everyone will agree. Are there definitive criteria to justify a particular quality? Some claim they can quantify qualities such as these but that is contentious. In contrast, in condensed matter physics it is possible to give objective criteria that distinguish different states of matter. A state can only exist under specific external conditions, including defined ranges of parameters such as temperature and pressure. This chapter describes the clear signatures of transitions between different states that are observed as these parameters are varied. Some of the many known states of matter will be introduced including superconductors, superfluids, and magnets. On the way we will learn about “dry ice”, how to convert graphite into diamond, and how freeze-dried food is made.

Abrupt changes in properties

If you put some ice cubes in one empty glass and water in another, the ice does not change its shape, whereas water takes the shape of the glass. Solids are rigid and liquids are not. The distinct change from one state to another can be detected by observing an abrupt change or discontinuity in physical properties. For example, ice (solid water) has a different density to liquid water. This is evident because ice floats. The solid state of water has a lower density than the liquid state. To put it another way, water expands when it freezes. That’s why water pipes can burst if they freeze in cold weather.

A transition between two distinct states of matter is an example of a tipping point: a small change in a system variable can produce large changes in the system. For example, changing the temperature of water from +1 °C to -1 °C can produce a qualitative change in the system's properties. The water changes from liquid to solid. Tipping points occur in a wide range of physical, biological, and social systems. Examples include a stock market crash, the outbreak of an epidemic, and the operation of a room thermostat. Tipping points show that quantitative differences can become qualitative differences.

Extract from Chapter 2, Condensed Matter Physics: A Very Short Introduction

What is condensed matter physics?

 Every day we encounter a diversity of materials: liquids, glass, ceramics, metals, crystals, magnets, plastics, semiconductors, foams, … These materials look and feel different from one another. Their physical properties vary significantly: are they soft and squishy or hard and rigid? Shiny, black, or colourful? Do they absorb heat easily? Do they conduct electricity? The distinct physical properties of different materials are central to their use in technologies around us: smartphones, alloys, semiconductor chips, computer memories, cooking pots, magnets in MRI machines, LEDs in solid state lighting, and fibre optic cables. Consequently, the science of materials attracts researchers in a wide range of disciplines: physics, chemistry, biology, mathematics, and the varieties of engineering (electrical, chemical, mechanical, material…). But why do different materials have different physical properties? 

There are more than one hundred different types of atoms, or chemical elements, in the universe. Any material is composed of a specific collection of different atoms, and they are arranged in a particular spatial pattern within the material. A central question is: 

How are the physical properties of a material related to the properties of the atoms from which the material is made?

Extract from Chapter 1, Condensed Matter Physics: A Very Short Introduction